Criterion Sunday 59: Il portiere di notte (The Night Porter, 1974)

When the Wikipedia entry namechecks “Nazisploitation” in its write-up, you expect to hate a film (or you expect to love it; to each their own). The Night Porter is certainly troubling — dealing with the sado-masochistic relationship between a former Nazi officer and a young woman he had abused during the war — but it’s clearly meant to be. It also treads a lot more delicately than that inelegant portmanteau word I started with. It’s the late-1950s, and Dirk Bogarde’s Max is working as a porter at a hotel and expecting to be called to trial for his wartime activities any day. There’s a circle of acquaintances and lawyers who are helping him to avoid the worst charges, and there’s a dark sense that maybe this is how it was in the aftermath of World War II for the disgraced Nazi officers. When Charlotte Rampling’s Lucia arrives at his hotel, they make eye contact and immediately you get the sense of some dark past, which is brought out through flashbacks. It’s a nasty film but not one that wallows in the nastiness; its characters are compromised, but perhaps not as much as you feel they should be; and there’s an uneasy way it works towards a resolution — the only resolution perhaps that the film could have, realistically.

FILM REVIEW: Criterion Collection
Director/Writer Liliana Cavani; Cinematographer Alfio Contini; Starring Dirk Bogarde, Charlotte Rampling; Length 118 minutes.

Seen at a friend’s home (DVD), London, Sunday 25 October 2015.

StreetDance (2010)

It wouldn’t be a stretch to say that the dance film genre — which can surely thank the Step Up series for its recent proliferation — is a bit predictable. Genres can be that way, and ones that emphasise physical performance over acting or writing need simple and recognisable structures. Opera, for example, trades on hackneyed plots and tropes, and it’s no different with the dance film. We have our kinetic urban protagonists, who come into conflict with the established authority as they progress towards a final showdown that will gain them credibility and respect amongst their peers. As a British entry into this nascent genre, StreetDance (or StreetDance 3D as it’s more commonly called, though I didn’t watch it in 3D) is a perfectly satisfying film. It does the stuff it needs to do well, and seems to be having fun with it.

It’s possible that some of my enjoyment of the film comes from its London locations — and specifically the way they don’t quite match up geographically (there are also plenty of gratuitous tourist images too, less interesting to me) — but I think there’s a core of a good drama here. Nichola Burley plays Carly, whose boyfriend Jay at the start of the film has just resigned as leader of their dance crew, turning his back in one stroke on both the crew and his relationship with Carly. This exposition is dealt with in a breezy and perfunctory manner, preferring to bring the focus swiftly to Carly, as she must step up as leader and find the group a new rehearsal space (they lost theirs with Jay’s departure). This leads them, somehow, to a ballet school, where Helena (played by Charlotte Rampling) sees Carly’s potential and offers them space if they take on some of her dancers, who are failing to connect emotionally with their material.

If it all seems a bit far-fetched, then sure, it is. But it’s easy to go along with it, because Burley and the dancers are all so passionate about doing what they do — and this, within the film’s narrative, is after all what Helena has spotted in them and wants to nurture. There are sideplots — like Carly’s budding relationship with ballet dancer Tomas (Richard Winsor), like her younger brother Eddie’s unrecognised dance talents, like the conflict between Helena and the other ballet teachers, like ex-boyfriend Jay’s involvement with rival crew The Surge (rather robotic in movement, and with a fascist uniformed aesthetic: they’re the bad guys) — but it’s all subservient to the performance setpieces, and for the most part these are all good fun.

I think anyone going into this film knows whether they are likely to respond positively or not. It may not change any minds about the genre, but if you enjoy dance films like Step Up 2: The Streets, then this is every bit as fun, just with British accents.

StreetDance 3D film posterCREDITS
Directors Max Giwa and Dania Pasquini; Writer Jane English; Cinematographer Sam McCurdy; Starring Nichola Burley, Richard Winsor, Charlotte Rampling; Length 98 minutes.
Seen at a friend’s home (DVD) [2D], London, Monday 1 July 2013.